How did FSFE go astray?

To help eliminate gossip and innuendo, we've updated the About page with a brief, fact-based summary of how FSFE ran off the rails. We hope this clarifies some ambiguity, the crisis in FSFE has breen brewing for a long time and didn't spontaneously arrive with any one volunteer or decision.

In 1985, the FSF was founded by Richard Stallman.

In 2001, a group of volunteers split from FSF and started using the name FSF Europe, now FSFE, for a new organization. They promised to be subject to an agreement with FSF but they abandoned the agreement and stubbornly continued using the name FSFE anyway.

In 2009, these people promised volunteers that they would be better than the FSF by giving volunteers membership, as Fellows and giving them permission to vote.

In 2016, Elias Diem, a Fellow in Switzerland invited Richard Stallman from the real FSF to speak at a joint FSF-FSFE event.

Diem subsequently died in an accident.

Shortly afterwards, FSFE received a EUR 150,000 bequest.

In 2017, after using the FSF-derived name to raise more than EUR 1,000,000 from Fellows, the FSFE decided to remove the Fellows and elections from the constitution. They implemented the constitutional change shortly afterwards and started spreading rumours about the last elected representative. This has snow-balled into a full-scale vendetta, stalking the former representative in other organizations and publishing obviously false accusations in various documents.

By removing the elections and giving voting rights to staff, they turned the organization into a corporate lobbyist. Budgets show significant annual income from Google. This is not the same structure as the organization that a Fellow decided to include in his will before leaving a EUR 150,000 bequest.

The last elected Fellowship representative resigned in disgust.

As the Fellowship is not in the FSFE constitution any more, it is now an independent organization.

The outgoing representative simply forked the Fellowship mailing list to FSFellowship to be under control of the Fellowship, not FSFE. As the last representative elected by the Fellowship, this was clearly within his mandate. FSFE belligerents have tried to question whether he had the authority to do this, yet it is those same people who pushed the Fellowship out of the constitution.

In 2019, Richard Stallman resigned as president of the FSF after a campaign of harassment. Some disgruntled FSF and GNU supporters joined the Fellowship too.

As of 2020, FSFE is also taking money from Microsoft. Any deceased Fellows who gave money to FSFE, believing they were supporting Stallman's vision, would turn in their graves.